
Third time’s the charm, as the saying goes. This was my third attempt to see How to Catch Creation. I was originally scheduled to attend on January 17, 2026, but changed my plans in anticipation of a far-right wing protest slated to end in the Cedar-Riverside neighborhood that Theatre in the Round calls home. I rescheduled for Friday, January 23, but that performance was canceled in observance of the statewide general strike. I almost cut my losses and accepted that I simply wasn’t going to see it.
But I kind of love Theatre in the Round, and earlier this season, for the first time in probably a decade, I had missed their annual Agatha Christie play when my stepmom passed away. I didn’t want to miss another show. And my God, am I glad I didn’t. The production is only running one more week, closing on February 8th. If you can make it to one of the remaining performances, I highly recommend you do so.

I’m not entirely sure what I was expecting going in. I had read the synopsis on the theatre’s website, but it didn’t really sink in, because this play wasn’t what I expected at all, and it’s unlike anything else I’ve ever seen at Theatre in the Round. I think it’s representative of the changes we’ve seen at TRP over the last several years, particularly since the arrival of their current Executive Director, Larisa Netterlund. We’ve seen more risks being taken. I’m not sure the audience has fully caught up with what’s happening at TRP yet, but I hope word spreads and programming like this continues.
How to Catch Creation, by Christina Anderson, weaves together the lives of six characters in San Francisco, four in 2014 and two in 1966–67. Griffin, a man recently released from prison after spending 25 years incarcerated following a wrongful conviction, reconnects with his best friend Tami, a painter who runs an art school. Both are in their mid-forties. They each come into contact with one half of a younger couple in their mid-twenties: Stokes, a painter, and his girlfriend Riley, a computer programmer.

Tami and Riley meet when Riley confronts her about why Stokes’ application to her school was rejected. Griffin and Stokes bond in a park over their shared love of the work of Black feminist author G.K. Marche. We also see Marche and her partner Natalie in the 1960s, and events in that timeline echo powerfully in the present-day story.
I think I expected this play to be about the creative process, but that turns out to be only a small part of it. It’s about the desire to create: Stokes wants to paint, then write a novel; Tami wants to paint; G.K. writes; even Griffin longs to create a new life. But what the play is really about is connection, the heartaches, sacrifices, joys, the need to be seen and heard, and the desire to reach out to another human being, whether for friendship or for love.

The cast features Duck Washington, a Stages of MN favorite, as Griffin. Washington brings an almost Zen quality to the role, creating a portrait of a man who long ago made peace with the inequities of life. His calm and openness make Stokes’ desire to seek out his advice mirror our own. Lyreshia Ghostlon-Green, the only other performer I was familiar with going in, plays Natalie in a role punctuated by moments of fairly intense, at least for Theatre in the Round, sexuality.
The rest of the cast was new to me, but I sincerely hope they appear in many future productions, because they are all terrific. This play contains conflict and even betrayal, but there isn’t a single character you don’t like. That’s certainly a testament to Anderson’s writing, but it’s also a credit to the performers. Every one of them creates a character you care about, whose longings and struggles you internalize. I found myself unexpectedly tearing up in the final moments. Faithful readers know that’s not entirely unusual for me, but the way it crept up on me surprised me and revealed just how deeply these six characters had seeped into my heart.

I was going to name my favorites among the performers who were new to me, and then realized I’d be listing all of them. So here they are: Tia Tanzer as Tami, Izzy Maxwell as Riley, Noah Branch as Stokes, Mary Cannon as G.K. Marche, and Abdoulie Ceesay, who appears briefly in a non-speaking role just before intermission and then vanishes until curtain call. (What play does that?) It’s wild, but his role is deeply consequential, and while you don’t see him for long, you do see more of him than the other performers.
I also want to give major props to Director Vanessa Brooke Agnes and Set Designer Kejia Yu for making this tapestry of stories flow so seamlessly. There are a lot of scenes in this play, which often leads to clunky transitions and broken momentum. Here, the storytelling never pauses. Locations shift fluidly with the introduction of a prop or a performer. Sometimes scenes from different timelines unfold simultaneously. It feels organic and effortless, when in reality it’s the result of precise writing and incredibly thoughtful execution by everyone onstage and backstage.
Lastly, a note on Jacourtney Mountain-Bluhm’s costumes, sometimes in a show like this even though it takes place over the course of months, the actors find themselves wearing the same costumes in about every scene. Not here, it feels like there is a new costume for every scene and as I mentioned, there are a lot of scenes! I don’t usually notice costumes that much, but I noticed and appreciated the effort.
How to Catch Creation runs through February 8 at Theatre in the Round. I urge you to see it before it closes. This is a deeply satisfying play, brought to life by a cast of mostly unfamiliar but thoroughly compelling performers.
For more information and tickets, visit:
https://www.theatreintheround.org/howtocatchcreation/

Watch the 2025 TCTB Awards on the latest episode of The Stages of MN YouTube Show!! https://bit.ly/TSOMNEp25YouTube
Don’t rely on Facebook or Instagram algorithms to keep you in the loop about great shows. Subscribe and have every post from The Stages of MN delivered straight to your inbox. It’s the best way to make sure you never miss out on the theater action. To subscribe on a computer, enter your email address on the home page (right-hand side) and click subscribe. On mobile, scroll to the bottom of the page to find the same option. You can also follow me on Facebook @thestagesofmn and on Instagram thestagesofmn.

The Stages of MN YouTube channel is home to the weekly Stages of MN Show. You can watch it by clicking here. Be sure to check out the latest episodes and subscribe so you’ll always know when a new one drops. Not sure you agree with one of my takes? I’m also part of the Twin Cities Theater Bloggers (TCTB), where you can find review roundups from my colleagues and me. Follow us on Facebook at @TwinCitiesTheaterBloggers.


You must be logged in to post a comment.