
The Gilbert & Sullivan Very Light Opera Company (GSVLOC) could just as easily be named the Gilbert & Sullivan Very Silly Opera Company (GSVSOC), as G&S operas are awfully silly in the best possible way. Their latest production of The Pirates of Penzance is a departure from the version I reviewed in 2022. This new adaptation has been reconceived and revised by director Joe Andrews, with music direction by Dr. Randal Buikema. The subtitle is Love and Duty in the Old West, which is their way of saying they’ve converted it into a Western. The wonderful thing about the G&S oeuvre, much like the works of Shakespeare, is that they are now in the public domain, and as such, liberties like this can be taken with the productions. This allows for some wonderfully creative interpretations, like this one.
GSVLOC is an unusual company in that they perform only the works of Gilbert and Sullivan, and have been doing so in rotation since 1979. Sometimes what you need to do is find out what you’re good at and do that. GSVLOC is very good at staging the works of G&S. Unlike what we usually think of when we say “opera,” these productions don’t require captions so you can understand what everyone is singing. The lyrics are in English, and the singing isn’t so stylized as to be unintelligible. They’re easy to follow, well sung, and performed with a wonderful sense of humor. What’s so remarkable about these works is how modern the humor feels, despite being, in the case of The Pirates of Penzance, over 140 years old. It’s the sort of opera you can safely bring the whole family to, as the humor is universal.
The plot centers around Frederic, who was apprenticed to prairie pirates as a young boy due to his nursemaid Ruth mishearing his father’s instructions. As the opera opens, Frederic has turned 21, and the prairie pirates are throwing a party for him, as this marks the end of his indentured servitude. Frederic reveals to the Pirate King that he has stayed with them out of a sense of duty, even though he knew it was a mistake. But now that he is free, he feels his duty is to eradicate the prairie pirates. Parting from the pirates, Frederic comes across a party of young women, the daughters of General Stanley, who is, of course, the very model of a modern Mormon general. That’s right, they’re Mormons, and there are some little jokes peppered throughout the show about that. He falls in love with the one daughter who will have him despite his past association with prairie pirates. Her name is Mabel.
Just when all seems too good to be true, the pirates arrive and attempt to make off with the General’s daughters. Luckily, the General knows of these tenderhearted pirates and their weakness for orphans. He lies to the Pirate King, telling him that he is an orphan, and so the pirates leave empty-handed. In Act II, just before Frederic is about to lead the sheriff and his posse against the pirates, the Pirate King and Ruth pay him a visit and point out a paradox they thought he might find humorous. It seems Frederic was born on February 29, in a leap year, so technically he is only a little over five years old. Thanks to his overdeveloped sense of duty, Frederic returns to the ranks of the prairie pirates and plans to remain with them until 1940, when he will have had 21 birthdays. Mabel, as any young woman in love would, has agreed to wait for him. Silliness continues to ensue.
The Howard Conn Fine Arts Center is not a large theater or stage, but somehow it manages to hold a cast of 30 performers. True, about 20 of them are unnamed pirates, deputies, daughters, and their mothers, but the sound they make together is impressive. Graham Remple plays Frederic with an aw-shucks, do-the-right-thing amble that works well for a character who is both so good and so idiotic. The other standouts for me were Eric Sorum as the Pirate King and Tom Berg as General Stanley.
The production is under the musical direction of Randal A. Buikema, who, along with his orchestra, brings one of Sir Arthur Sullivan’s best-loved compositions to exquisite life. Michael Hoover’s set design does a nice job of representing the Old West, complete with actual tumbleweeds being pulled across the stage. The overture is used to present the audience with some context and history of America, and it is done with the company’s usual flair for humor.
GSVLOC’s production of The Pirates of Penzance, or Love & Duty in the Old West, is not as good as the more traditional staging I saw in 2022. But they do have fun with the setting change, and there are some new lyrics and lines that land perfectly with the audience. It may have been me, but I had a harder time than usual hearing some of the performers and making out the lyrics they were singing. Mary Kettlewell, who plays Mabel, was particularly difficult to hear.
The Pirates of Penzance, or Love & Duty in the Old West runs through November 22 at the Howard Conn Fine Arts Center. For more information and to purchase tickets, go to https://gsvloc.org/on-stage/

Don’t forget to keep an eye on the new website 79 Seconds on Stage a free and full guide to local theatre in the Twin Cities.
Don’t rely on Facebook or Instagram algorithms to keep you in the loop about great shows. Subscribe and have every post from The Stages of MN delivered straight to your inbox. It’s the best way to make sure you never miss out on the theater action. To subscribe on a computer, enter your email address on the home page (right-hand side) and click subscribe. On mobile, scroll to the bottom of the page to find the same option. You can also follow me on Facebook @thestagesofmn and on Instagram thestagesofmn.

The Stages of MN YouTube channel is home to the Stages of MN Show. You can watch it by clicking here. Be sure to check out the latest episodes and subscribe so you’ll always know when a new one drops. Not sure you agree with one of my takes? I’m also part of the Twin Cities Theater Bloggers (TCTB), where you can find review roundups from my colleagues and me. Follow us on Facebook at @TwinCitiesTheaterBloggers.






You must be logged in to post a comment.