Holmes/Poirot Gets Long Awaited World Premiere at Park Square Theatre Proves Worth the Wait

Holmes/Poirot the new play from local favorite Jeffrey Hatcher and Steve Hendrickson finally takes the stage at Park Square Theatre where it was originally scheduled as their annual Summer whodunnit in 2023. To be clear, the delay was to do with Park Square’s Financial struggles, which appear thankfully to be righted, and not an issue with the play itself. This play along with Hatcher’s Holmes and Watson are the most satisfying and clever bits of Sherlockian fiction to come along in a long time. I don’t keep up on all the Holmes pastiches but I’ve read a few over the last year, such as the most recent Nicholas Meyer Novels and Robert J. Harris’s A Study in Crimson. For sheer cleverness and enjoyment, nothing tops Hatchers ingenious mysteries. As with Holmes and Watson, the tag line left me unsure how well it would work. For Holmes Poirot it reads:

“Sherlock Holmes never lost a case. Or did he? In this new mystery Holmes comes up against his most diabolical adversary in a tale of intrigue, international politics, wine and murder. And he’s stymied. Enter Hercule Poirot 25 years later to investigate a new crime that rhymes with the first.”

Park Square Theatre Website

It reads like Holmes fails and Poirot comes in and solves it 25 years later, implying he’s the greater detective, which wasn’t what I wanted to see. In the end, while the tag line isn’t entirely disingenuous, in Act One Holmes doesn’t fail to solve the crime, he makes a choice to not reveal the solution, and that reason feels valid to Baker Street fans. Poirot solves another mystery all together in Act two and is aided by information from Holmes’ earlier case. Like the earlier Holmes and Watson, the script itself elements that turn those synopsis on their heads and lead you to twists not guessed at beforehand. Its been probably a decade since I finished my David Suchet Poirot watch, but parts of the Act Two felt like they were inspired by elements from the Christie Stories, the Golfing, the Tramp, the competition between Poirot and Inspector Giraud, I can’t remember if they all come from the same story or if they’re all separate elements from different stories. But it gave Act Two an authentic Christie feel, that felt as different in style from Act One as Conan Doyle’s writing does to Agatha Christie.

There is so much to love about the casting of this show. First the ingenious casting of Steve Hendrickson and Bob Davis in dual roles in which they swap playing the detective and the sidekick during the two Acts. Hendrickson plays Holmes with Davis as his Watson, roles they have played before. In Act Two Davis plays the detective Hercule Poirot with Hendrickson as his Captain Hastings. Perhaps surprisingly give their histories as Holmes and Watson, I enjoyed them even more as Poirot and Hastings. It’s perhaps the nature of the characters, there is a little more to do with the latter, as they are a tad more emotional and colorful duo. Davis’s Watson in the solid by the book gentleman Doctor, his Poirot is witty, and eccentric. Hendrickson’s Holmes is logical and a bit unemotional, whereas his Captain Hastings has more in common with Bertie Wooster than John Watson. These are fun characterizations made even more enjoyable by watching the complete changes these two leads make between the two acts. Other treats in the casting department, it’s great to see Daniel Petzold back at Park Square where he first drew our attention in Airness and Holmes and Watson. David Andrew Macdonald, who was brilliant last year in the Guthrie Theater’s Jeffrey Hatcher adaptation of Dial M for Murder, then stuck around to help out in the History plays, hopefully this means he’s decided to stay in town and add to our pool of Twin Cities Talent. Also nice to see the return of Stacia Rice to the stage, who gives a wonderful performance and is the one Actor who plays the same character in both Acts.

For mystery fans, Sherlockians, and Poirot devotees Holmes/Poirot will feel like Christmas came early. The show runs through November 3rd at Park Square Theatre in St. Paul. For more information and to purchase tickets go to https://parksquaretheatre.org/box-office/20242025-season

Tired of missing reviews from The Stages of MN? Do you find yourself left out when all your friends are talking about that great new play that you didn’t even know about? Never fear, that need never happen again. Now you too can subscribe and have every post from The Stages of MN sent directly to your email box. No more hoping the algorithm works in your favor and you actually see a post on facebook or Instagram. No relying on so-called friends to tip you to the best shows in town. To subscribe on your computer: from the home page on the right, enter your email address and click subscribe. On your mobile device scroll to the bottom of the page and do the same. You can also follow me on Facebook, @thestagesofmn click follow and on Instagram thestagesofmn. You can also read some of my reviews syndicated on the MN Playlist website https://minnesotaplaylist.com/ from time to time.