Grumpy Old Men the Musical From Minneapolis Musical Theatre is a Rather Fun Adaptation of the 90’s Film.

Grumpy Old Men: The Musical, based on the 1993 film, is a perfect fit for the theater company Minneapolis Musical Theatre, which specializes in “Rare Musicals. Well Done.” This is certainly a rarely performed musical and, as is often the case, there’s a reason for that. The show itself isn’t of the quality that a larger theater like Theater Latté Da or the Guthrie Theater is likely to mount. But what MMT does is take those not-quite-hit-worthy efforts and, as their slogan promises, do them well.

The smaller budget, the mix of professional and community theater actors, and sets that lean more on creativity than realism are exactly what make a show like this work. To see Tyler Michaels King, Erin Capello, Tod Petersen, and Roland Hawkins II perform this on the Guthrie thrust stage, surrounded by a set that cost 20 times MMT’s budget, would shine far too bright a light on the material. At this level, we forgive the show’s imperfections, in fact, they become part of its charm. I don’t know if a lavish set could be any more charming than the clever creations scenic designer Maggie Mae Sulentic has devised. Actually, I do know: it would be a step down.

This material was never meant to stand beside Les Misérables or even Legally Blonde. Just as the original film wasn’t aiming for the magic of When Harry Met Sally or Groundhog Day, it was meant to be fun, light entertainment. And if memory serves, it was. I haven’t seen it since 1993, but I remember laughing and, despite it being aimed at people much older than my then tender 21 years, finding it quite enjoyable.

That’s what this is, too. Though I will say, I don’t think most modern 21-year-olds would find it as entertaining as I did. The sweet spot here seems to be my age and older, which, thankfully for MMT, my highly scientific observational poll suggests makes up about 75% of theatergoers. The trick, as with any show, is finding that audience and making sure they know about it. So if you’re under 40 and this doesn’t seem like your cup of tea, let your parents know, they’re going to have a blast.

The grumpy old men of the title are two former friends who have been feuding for more than 30 years. Their rivalry gets a fresh burst of energy when they both fall for a new widow who moves in across the street. Her home furnishings, especially a statue of her late husband, are among the many clever set pieces that add delightful touches to the production.

There’s also a subplot involving their children that might feel unnecessary, if not for the charming performances of Jillian Bader and James Lane, who win you over completely. Jim Ahrens and Ward Eames play the titular grumps, trading barbs and insults like seasoned pros. There are also a couple of real crowd-pleasers. Punky, played by Lisa Denninger, is essentially the show’s version of Woody from Cheers, and if you don’t know what Cheers is, this show probably isn’t for you. Denninger nails the comedy, but she also surprises vocally, arguably the strongest singer in the cast, if I’m being honest (and you know I always am). The other standout is Michael Fischetti as Grandpa, the role made famous by Burgess Meredith in the film. He’s just as funny, and just as inappropriate here.

Grumpy Old Men: The Musical is a great show to take in with a group of friends, say, ages 50 to 87. It runs through April 19th at the Conn Theater in Minneapolis. For more information and tickets, visit https://www.aboutmmt.org/2025-26-season/

The Stages of MN delivered straight to your inbox. It’s the best way to make sure you never miss out on the theater action. To subscribe on a computer, enter your email address on the home page (right-hand side) and click subscribe. On mobile, scroll to the bottom of the page to find the same option. You can also follow me on Facebook @thestagesofmn and on Instagram thestagesofmn.