Human Error From 100 Percent Human Theatre is No Mistake It’s Funny and Thoughtful

Matt Berdahl, Katie Consamus, Darius Dotch, Stephanie Cousins Photo Courtesy of 100 Percent Human Theatre

Human Error was a delightful surprise, and reminds us that the best way to bring people together is through laughter. The story involves two couples, one right-wing and the other left-wing, brought together by the incompetence of a fertility clinic doctor who has implanted the fertilized embryo of Madelyn and Keenan into the womb of Heather and Jim. The couples try to navigate a relationship together while Heather carries the baby to term for them. Faithful readers will no doubt know by now that I get out of bed on the left side. The playwright, I think, clearly leans that way as well, but the play itself is remarkably balanced. While the right-wing couple, Heather and Jim, and Jim particularly, perhaps play a little more upon caricatures, it is Keenan and Madelyn, Madelyn particularly, who seem slightly less open-minded. The point of the show is not to proclaim the right or the left the winner, but to show us the common ground, the ways in which people are still people, whatever their political beliefs.

The more time the characters spend together, the more they connect and find that they can actually become friends. I found myself identifying closely with Keenan, played by Darius Dotch. He is logical, believes what I believe, but has an easier time keeping control of his anti-Republican feelings. There is a scene early in the show, before the couples meet, where Keenan and Madelyn are sitting in their car outside the other couple’s house before going in. Madelyn asks Keenan if he will F them up if needed. His response felt like it came directly from my life. There are several moments during that scene that solidified my identification with Keenan, including his insistence that all the declarations Madelyn was making were generalizations that might not be true, since they hadn’t actually met the other couple yet.

It may sound like the play is all about ideology, but that is simply the background against which this story of two couples who would never have even met otherwise unfolds. There is one segment near the end where an argument occurs based on the two women’s opposing belief systems, and it is the argument that Heather makes that is the most compelling. It will not change anyone’s stance on the issue, but she does expose the hypocrisy that those of us on the left side of the center sometimes turn a blind eye to. But above all else, this is a comedy, and it is genuinely funny.

I brought my son Alex with me, and he loved the play as well. He’s a much harder-to-please theatergoer than I am, with an almost allergic reaction to sentimentality. This script plays on our political leanings through humor without ever villainizing anyone. Even the doctor who screws up the implantation, played by director Joy Donley’s husband, Michael Pearce Donley, is treated as a comedic figure. His performance is cartoonish, which is exactly the right tone for that role. Given that, it’s surprising how different in tone the rest of the performances are, and that it all works so well.

The final couple of scenes, when the baby is coming and that big-issue argument transpires, are surprisingly moving. Yes, in what is primarily a comedy, these performers made my eyes leak a little bit. That is entirely due to the performances of Stephanie Cousins as Madelyn and Katie Consamus as Heather. Dotch and Matt Berdahl, who plays Jim, are both great, but they have a very set function, which they play perfectly, being broad when needed or subtle, depending on what is required to make the joke or scene work. But Cousins and Consamus are asked to do a lot more, and they are both absolutely brilliant.

Human Error runs through December 5 at Art House North in St. Paul. It’s a former church that I’ve only ever been to one other time, but it’s a wonderfully intimate space that works perfectly for this show. As an added treat, there are additional post-show activities. Friday features a quiz game hosted by Fifty Hats Games. Saturday matinees are followed by a chair yoga class taught by Katie Consamus, and on Saturday nights, stick around for Joy Donley’s homemade cookies and a brief mini-introduction to a workshop called “Skills for Disagreeing Better.” For more information and to purchase tickets, go to https://www.givemn.org/story/humanerror.

Don’t forget to keep an eye on the new website  79 Seconds on Stage a free and full guide to local theatre in the Twin Cities.

Don’t rely on Facebook or Instagram algorithms to keep you in the loop about great shows. Subscribe and have every post from The Stages of MN delivered straight to your inbox. It’s the best way to make sure you never miss out on the theater action. To subscribe on a computer, enter your email address on the home page (right-hand side) and click subscribe. On mobile, scroll to the bottom of the page to find the same option. You can also follow me on Facebook @thestagesofmn and on Instagram thestagesofmn.

The Stages of MN YouTube channel is home to the Stages of MN Show. You can watch it by clicking here. Be sure to check out the latest episodes and subscribe so you’ll always know when a new one drops. Not sure you agree with one of my takes? I’m also part of the Twin Cities Theater Bloggers (TCTB), where you can find review roundups from my colleagues and me. Follow us on Facebook at @TwinCitiesTheaterBloggers.


Discover more from The Stages of MN

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply