A Christmas Carol Still Has it, at Least For Me, at the Guthrie Theater

The cast of A Christmas Carol Photo by Dan Norman

It’s hard to get through the holiday season without experiencing at least one version of A Christmas Carol, and the Guthrie Theater’s annual production seems particularly inescapable for me. I usually end up seeing three or four versions each year, and because it’s such a busy time both theatrically and personally, I always tell myself I’ll skip the Guthrie’s for once. But then someone in my inner circle really wants to go, and they pull me back in. Thankfully, it’s always a journey worth repeating, and one I’m glad I never miss.

This marks the 51st production of the Guthrie’s A Christmas Carol and the fifth year of the current adaptation by Lavina Jadhwani, first performed in 2021. This year’s staging is directed by Addie Gorlin-Han, based on the original direction by Joseph Haj, the Guthrie’s Artistic Director.

After so many years and so many versions, I’m still amazed by this story’s capacity to captivate me. There’s something enduring about Dickens’s tale of reflection and redemption. Its familiarity allows it to be endlessly adaptable. The core plot and themes appear throughout modern storytelling. Everyone has a favorite version: for my son Alex, who was my plus-one this year, it’s Patrick Stewart’s made-for-TV version; for me, it’s the 1951 British film starring Alastair Sim. Alex wasn’t completely won over by this stage version, perhaps he holds his favorite too tightly to let another in. That’s fair and I think something we’ve all experienced from time to time. I’m happy to say that once again the Guthrie’s version did completely win me over. And I had the telltale tears on my cheeks at the end as proof.

Last year my review focused on changes I wasn’t sure were new, this year I had the same thoughts. Was that second hug Bob Cratchit gives Scrooge there last time? Was the astonishingly quick transport of Scrooge from the trapdoor to his bed new? Regardless, it all works beautifully. There aren’t many cast changes this season, but it was great to see Daniel Petzold join as Young Scrooge and Aimee K. Bryant in a newly credited role as Kitty’s sister Dahlia. Kitty herself finally gets a name after years of being listed simply as “Fred’s wife.” Both are welcome additions. I also loved seeing Noah Hynick, apparently on loan from Lyric Arts, joining the ensemble. Hopefully it’s just a matter of time before he takes on larger roles at the Guthrie.

The elements that have wowed me in past productions continue to shine. Nathan Huberty’s Ghost of Christmas Future, in a haunting costume by Toni-Leslie James, remains nightmarish enough to give the wee ones a genuine scare. The moment when the ghost emerges from the darkness, engulfed in fog and towering over a cowering Scrooge, is pure theatrical adrenaline—especially from my front-row seat. Alex said that moment almost triggered his fight-or-flight response. The set design by Matt Saunders and lighting by Yi Zhao strike a perfect balance between detailed realism and expressionistic atmosphere. Sound designer Mikaal Sulaiman and music director Jason Hansen weave together Jane Shaw’s evocative score, traditional carols, and well-timed sound effects to create a rich, immersive experience.

The one scene that still puzzles me is the brief moment when Scrooge and the Ghost of Christmas Present observe the ship at sea. I know it’s in the book, and many adaptations include it, but it’s so short and requires such elaborate staging, complete with, to be fair, excellent projections and a separate set piece, that I can’t help wondering if the payoff justifies the effort. I promise to stop harping on this by next year; I know it’s a dead horse.

As I’ve said before: if you’ve never seen A Christmas Carol at the Guthrie, it’s actually required by the state constitution once you’ve lived here more than five years. And if you’ve seen it before, even this same adaptation, it absolutely rewards repeat viewings. Unless, of course, you’re fiercely loyal to Patrick Stewart’s version; then all bets are off. I’m not sure how this story keeps reaching me year after year, but I think Dickens’s source material is simply too brilliant to ever grow old. Its message remains timeless: our fellow man is the business of all of us.

A Christmas Carol runs through December 28 at the Guthrie Theater in Minneapolis. For more information and tickets, visit guthrietheater.org.

Don’t rely on Facebook or Instagram algorithms to keep you in the loop about great shows. Subscribe and have every post from The Stages of MN delivered straight to your inbox. It’s the best way to make sure you never miss out on the theater action. To subscribe on a computer, enter your email address on the home page (right-hand side) and click subscribe. On mobile, scroll to the bottom of the page to find the same option. You can also follow me on Facebook @thestagesofmn and on Instagram thestagesofmn.

The Stages of MN YouTube channel is home to the weekly Stages of MN Show. You can watch it by clicking here. Be sure to check out the latest episodes and subscribe so you’ll always know when a new one drops. Not sure you agree with one of my takes? I’m also part of the Twin Cities Theater Bloggers (TCTB), where you can find review roundups from my colleagues and me. Follow us on Facebook at @TwinCitiesTheaterBloggers.

Scrooge in Rouge Still Brings the Laughs at Open Eye Theatre

Tom Reed, Abilene Olson, and Maren Ward Photo by Bruce Silcox

*Note much of this review was adapted from my 2023 review of the show as I got it right the first time.

There are a lot of shows with Christmas themes this time of year, and several that are quite funny, but in terms of being a consistently funny, audience pleasing production, this one probably takes the fruit cake. I saw it last year and in the busy Holiday season was probably going to skip seeing it again to make room for new shows. Then I heard that there was a cast change and the new cast member happens to be on my Must See List so I booked the show again and am glad I did because it’s such a fun show. The premise is a British Music Hall production of A Christmas Carol where 17 of the 20 performers are out sick with food poisoning. So the three healthy performers play all the roles, as of course, for Queen and Country, the show must go on. Some of the humor comes from the backstage plotline of how the three will perform a script meant for 20. While much more comes from the music hall tradition of double entendres, silly word play, and wacky characters. Some of the jokes are old, but then so are many of the audience members. Old or new, obvious or out of the blue, it’s the delivery that makes the show. These are three performers who are brilliantly cast, they are completely believable as over the top music hall performers. This is the show to go to with your group of friends who love a good laugh, a great time will be had by all, respectful rowdiness is encouraged.

The cast is expertly accompanied on piano by Patrick Adkins who has the odd line as well but, declines to take the role of Tiny Tim when called upon. Will you answer the call? If you don’t want to be asked, avoid the aisle seats, you’ve been warned. Now when I say the three performers take on the roles of 20, I really mean two of them do. You see Maren Ward who plays Vesta Virile, a male impersonator mainly plays Ebenezer Scrooge, ge sund heit. She is excellent as Scrooge and as the center around which all the chaos revolves. Neal Skoy who played Charlie Schmaltz in the production is in New York City performing in Big Apple Circus. So this year the role is played by a The Stages of MN favorite Tom Reed, who in turn plays everyone from Bob Cratchit, to the Ghost of Christmas Past. My favorite roles of Reeds were that of Scrooge’s nephew Freddie and Bob Cratchit. As Freddie he plays it as a cartoon version of Whodehouse’s Bertie Wooster, and Cratchit is a lovesick softie. Abilene Olson is the the singing soubrette Lottie Obbligato, I’m not going to tell you what that means, I had to google it and so do you. Lottie makes it clear she’s happy to take in a little extra cash for extra services, wink-wink, nudge-nudge. Olson has a wonderful singing voice which serves her well, legitimately but also for comic effect. She’s the sauciest and bawdiest of the trio and gets a lot of laughs with her thinly disguised euphemisms. I’d have to say my favorite role she plays is that of Lottie herself. As opposed to Schmaltz, who is listed in the program as a “character actor” and thus tries to create a new personality and look for each role. Lottie isn’t, and thus it’s perfectly fine that Olson let’s Lottie shine through quite a bit no matter what role she’s performing in the show, within the show. If that didn’t confuse you … can you explain it to me?

The show has a book and lyrics by Ricky Graham with music by Jefferson Turner, additional bits and bobs of material were added by Jeffery Roberson and Yvette Hargis. The production is Directed by the Open Eye Theatre Producing Artistic Director Joel Sass. Sass knows his space well and makes effective use of Open Eyes small stage and all it’s nooks, crannies, and trap doors. As is always the case with Open Eye productions, the look of the show is one of the stars. Michael Sommers set design and Kathy Kohl’s costumes are gorgeousities. There really is nothing quite like the designed theatricality of an Open Eye production, merely functional is never the aim. Every wall, every sign, every prop, every effect has to do more than exist, it has to add to the atmosphere of the piece. Helping achieve the look and overall feel of the show are the expert skills of Lighting Designer Bill Healey and Sound Engineer Dan Dukich. And I think a special shout out is due to Stage Manager Brian Hirt and Assistant Stage Manager Evelyn Kelly who keep the show flowing and one assumes helping the performers do their quick costume changes.

Highly recommended Scrooge in Rouge is a hilarious take on A Christmas Carol done in the tradition of the English Music Hall. The show runs through December 29th at Open Eye Theatre in South Minneapolis. For more information and to purchase tickets go to https://www.openeyetheatre.org/scrooge-in-rouge

A Christmas Carol Continues to Enchant as it Celebrates 50 Years at the Guthrie Theater

Cast of A Christmas Carol Photo by Dan Norman

Every year come November and December we are exposed to multiple version of of A Christmas Carol. From films to episodes of TV series that use it’s plot to stage productions. I’ll likely see at least three stage productions this season that are based off of it. This was the fourth production of the Guthrie’s latest adaptation of Charles Dickens’ classic A Christmas Carol and also marks it’s 50th Production overall. I’ve seen all four years of this current incarnation which was adapted by Lavina Jadhwani and first performed in the 2021 season. This years production is directed by Addie Gorlin-Han based on the original direction by Guthrie Artistic Director Joseph Haj. After spending time with so many versions of this story year after year I’m amazed at it’s capacity to captivate me each time. There is something so enduring about Dickens tale of reflection and redemption, and its familiarity to audiences, which accounts for its adaptability. It’s core plot and themes can be seen in so many different works. Even that other mainstay of the holiday season It’s a Wonderful Life shares DNA with it. In it, we see George Bailey’s past, then his present, and then an alternate reality which is what the Ghost of Christmas Future shows Scrooge, a possible future, but one that may not come to pass. Like Scrooge who changes his ways and embraces life, George changes his mind deciding it’s better to live and we get a happy ending for all.

What struck me this year is how fresh the production felt and a lot of details or moments that I either didn’t remember or are new. Being the fourth year in a row, knowing it was the same adaptation with the same sets, I admit I did entertain the idea of giving it a skip this year. So glad I didn’t. Now I’ve reviewed nearly 200 productions since I last saw A Christmas Carol at the Guthrie last fall, so I struggle to remember last years in detail. Are the things I noticed this year new or have they just slipped my memory? This year it felt like there were some different songs and more choreography between scenes, but that may not be the case at all. There is a scene before the Ghost of Christmas Past visits when the ensemble is forming the hands of the clock on stage as the hour between Midnight and one A.M. passes. This struck me as a really creative touch from Choreographer Regina Peluso, but was it new this year? I don’t know. The only change I am certain of are those of casting. There are a lot of the same actors but many of them have changed roles this year. After years in the role of Bob Cratchit, John Catron has been promoted to Fred, Scrooge’s nephew. This was due to former Fred, Eric Sharp moving into the role of the Ghost of Christmas Past. It also led to Tyler Michaels King taking on the role of Bob Cratchit leaving his role as Collector 1 and Dick Wilkins. That in turn leads to the addition this year of Max Wojtanowicz to the cast in those vacated roles. It’s very interesting to notice the changes that each performer brings to the roles and how that subtle changes the play as a whole and giving it a breath of fresh air. The biggest cast change this year is the replacement of Matthew Saldivar, who was very good in the role, but always struck me as a little too young, with David Beach who feels very age appropriate, is fantastic.

The things that wowed me in previous production continue to do so now. The Ghost of Christmas Future portrayed by Nathan Huberty in a costume created by Toni-Leslie James is still effectively nightmarish and might give the very wee ones in the audience a genuine fright. The moment when the Ghost comes out of the darkness engulfed in fog to tower over a cowering Scrooge is truly a heart pounding moment. The set design by Matt Saunders in conjunction with the Lighting design by Yi Zhao manages to be both detailed and expressionistic. Sound Designer Mikaal Sulaiman and Musical Director Jason hansen also contribute greatly to the tone and atmosphere of the work whether through Composer Jane Shaw’s score, traditional Christmas carols, or well times sound effects. The one scene that has always been a head scratcher for me is when Scrooge and the Ghost of Christmas Present observe the ship out at sea. I know it’s from the book, I know many adaptations include it, I understand there is a point to it. But it’s so short and requires elaborate, and very effective projection, a separate set piece that has to be built and wheeled on and off the stage. I wonder if what it brings to the show ultimately justifies that build out and expense.

If you’ve never seen A Christmas Carol at the Guthrie it’s something you are required by the State Constitution to do at least once if you’ve lived her more than five years. If you’ve seen it before, even this very adaptation, I promise you it rewards on multiple viewings. I think the cast changes do shift the whole piece enough that you are going to find it remarkably fresh and entertaining. A Christmas Carol runs through December 29th at The Guthrie Theater in Minneapolis. For more information and to purchase tickets go to https://www.guthrietheater.org/shows-and-tickets/a-christmas-carol/

Tired of missing reviews from The Stages of MN? Do you find yourself left out when all your friends are talking about that great new play that you didn’t even know about? Never fear, that need never happen again. Now you too can subscribe and have every post from The Stages of MN sent directly to your email box. No more hoping the algorithm works in your favor and you actually see a post on facebook or Instagram. No relying on so-called friends to tip you to the best shows in town. To subscribe on your computer: from the home page on the right, enter your email address and click subscribe. On your mobile device scroll to the bottom of the page and do the same. You can also follow me on Facebook, @thestagesofmn click follow and on Instagram thestagesofmn. You can also read some of my reviews syndicated on the MN Playlist website https://minnesotaplaylist.com/ from time to time.